The easy take on After The Rain is that it's a continuation of John McLaughlin's 1993 return to high-powered jazz with the guitar-organ-drums format. True, but this studio recording actually improves on last year's Tokyo Live album by having the great Elvin Jones taking over for funky strongman Dennis Chambers on the traps and by having inspiring investigations of the Coltrane canon replace merely good playing on a program dominated by McLaughlin compositions. In a fashion, the guitarist's now following through in a big way on what he started with the Trane tribute song "Do You Hear The Voices You Left Behind?" on his 1978 album Johnny McLaughlin: Electric Guitarist.
McLaughlin plays with a dazzling sense of time and resourcefulness, ordering the notes just so in testimony to the acuity of his musical reasoning. When the tempos pick up, this world-class guitarist easefully crams bristling phrases into small spaces a la Trane, yet he's equally adept at mounting creative thoughts on passages that take their time unfolding. On Trane numbers "Crescent," "Naima" and "After The Rain," especially but not exclusively, his improvisations seem to ride on a strong spiritual bond with the past saxophone master. Even on the selections from outside the Trane realm, including Carla Bley's "Sing Me Softly Of The Blues" and his own "Encuentros," there's a certain piety to his playing, measured and unobtrusive, that appears to emanate from deep inside.
DeFrancesco, despite being more in his element playing Bobby Timmons and Irving Berlin than sizing up Coltrane, handles himself stirringly in many B-3 drones and discourses. Elvin Jones is Elvin Jones is Elvin Jones: His superb playing is shaped by firsthand experience with Trane and his music, of course, and he's an emphatic presence all over his kit, always creative to the highest degree and an inspiration to his two colleagues on the session.
Let the friendly arguments begin on whether or not After The Rain stands as the next pinnacle of McLaughlin's artistry after his brilliant album Extrapolation back in '69.

                       -Frank-John Hadley, down beat, November 1995